Meeting of the Motherboards: The Validity of Contracts Created by Algorithmic Traders
By Adam Adler
“[B]ug, n: An elusive creature living in a program that makes it incorrect. The activity of ‘debugging’, or removing bugs from a program, ends when people get tired of doing it, not when the bugs are removed.”—Datamation
Today’s stock market is dominated by high frequency algorithmic trading. Algorithmic trading refers to the practice of using pre-defined quantitative algorithms to determine when to buy and sell stocks. The algorithms are designed and implemented by so-called “quants,” analytical mathematicians and statisticians who attempt to discover and benefit from patterns in the market. High frequency trading typically involves the transfer of thousands of stocks per second. These exchanges take place automatically and are rarely reviewed. In most cases, the trading algorithms work well, allowing brokers to track prices, propose trades, and influence the market faster than ever before. But what happens when the algorithm fails to function as intended?
On May 6, 2010, “in the space of a few, hair-raising minutes, a breakdown in the market triggered by failures in computer-trading systems across the country caused stocks to plunge about 10%.”[1] A report later issued by the SEC found that the incident, dubbed the “flash crash,” was caused by a single erroneous sale. More recently, on August 1, 2012, Knight Capital, a high frequency trading group, was affected by a bug in its trading algorithms which ultimately caused it to lose over $440 million and 75% of its value in two days. These examples show how software errors in algorithmic trading can lead to a bizarre outcome in which two parties can be subject to an exchange that neither actually wants to happen. Even more problematically, as evidenced by the flash crash, these detrimental and involuntary transactions quickly propagate through the entire market, wreaking havoc on other trading algorithms and making it more likely that more traders will engage in unproductive, unexpected, and undesired exchanges.
It is a basic tenet of contract law that the formation of a valid contract requires a “meeting of the minds,” an agreement between the parties entering into the contract. It is generally recognized that such a meeting of the minds can exist even when parties to a contract use an automated algorithm to determine the details of the exchange. For example, contracts formed through eBay’s automated bidding system have been upheld by courts. But what are the limits to such automated exchanges? What constitutes a “meeting of the minds” for the purposes of an automated contract? Is it enough to rely on pre-approved trading algorithms, or should we condition a contract’s validity on the conformity of the transaction with a trader’s expectation of how the algorithm should function?
To answer these questions, the National Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws, an organization that seeks to promote uniformity in law, introduced the Uniform Computer Information Transactions Act (UCITA). While only two states have approved UCITA, courts may still look to the act for guidance. Section 206 deals with contracts created by “electronic agents.” Specifically, the act states that contracts entered into by automated systems should be binding unless the contract resulted “from fraud, electronic mistake, or the like.” The UCITA goes on to clarify “electronic mistake,” noting that there might not be a contract if, “because of aberrant programming or through an unexpected interaction of the two agents, operations indicating existence of a contract occur in circumstances that are not within the reasonable contemplation of the parties.”
This places high frequency algorithmic trading in something of a quandary. Because human involvement is needed to determine whether an interaction is “unexpected,” and because millions of transactions can take place before any independent determination can be made, trading algorithms will have no way of determining whether the exchanges produced by other high frequency traders are legitimate or whether they are the products of “unexpected” interactions, subject to future repudiation. That is, algorithms have no way of determining which trades “count” and should be used as criteria to determine future trades. Accordingly, under the UCITA, if traders could exercise their option to repudiate, high frequency trading would become functionally impossible.
If, on the other hand, “unexpected interactions” do not function as a basis for repudiation, if events such as the flash crash are to be expected, or if high frequency traders elect not to repudiate contracts formed from unexpected interactions[2], then, absent any additional oversight or regulation, there would be nothing preventing a sub-optimal trading algorithm from introducing undesired “phantom” trades into the market. High frequency trading would become little more than a game of collective Russian roulette, where each algorithmic exchange is a pull of the trigger, little more than an opportunity for a bug in the code to induce a superfluous algorithmic panic with the potential to destabilize the entire market with millions of undesired, yet legally enforceable, exchanges.
Indeed, given that it is not standard practice to repudiate trades based on software glitches, some think we have already reached the point of collective financial suicide. While the simple solution would be to stop performing these trades, the Federal Reserve could also implement better checks on errant systems to prevent one flawed algorithm from toppling the entire market. Whichever solution is implemented, it is clear that high frequency trading, as it exists now, is unsustainable, irresponsible, and, insofar as traders will be subject to exchanges which harm everyone and help no one, illogical.
[1] Scott Patterson, Breakdown: A Glimpse Inside the 'Flash Crash,' Wall St. J., June 10, 2012, http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405270230329660457745433006603989....
[2] Or, as is more likely the case, such repudiation would be impractical given that countless millions of trades would take place between the unexpected interaction and the desire to repudiate.


Comments
[url=http://www.leffs.com/lv.html]louis vuitton mens wallet[/url] About MattelFireworks close each day. The most popular, of course, is the Wishes display that lights up Cinderella's Castle, a sight that makes boomer parents think of sitting in front of the TV on Sunday night, and hence connects with their most cherished and elemental memories. Daddy, why are you crying? I'm just so happy. Look! It's Tinkerbell! And then it's over and, oh my God, you're trapped behind 9 million people.
[url=http://www.leffs.com/lv.html]louis vuitton coin purse[/url] From then on, Let me never forget this particular case, purchase the type people everywhere to find out photos, getting received endorsement beneath the mature mommy and also for you to compliment personally officially signed up as a pharmacist, for you to facilitate the very first 1 / 2 2011 these days, a final day of a wonderful depiction of our shift think consider this kind of child handbag nighttime.He saut茅s the watercress, mustard leaves, and wild onions, mixing in fresh almonds he picked from a friend's orchard and ghee made from Dumpster-dived butter, and we eat out of his soot-caked pans. From the perch on the cliff, the life of the sadhu seems reasonable. But I don't want to live in a cave. I like indoor plumbing (Suelo squats). I like electricity. Still, there's an obvious beauty in the simplicity of subsistence. It's an un-American notion these days. We don't revere our ascetics, and we dismiss the idea that money could be some kind of consensual delusion. For most of us, it's as real as the next house payment. Suelo doesn't take public assistance or use food stamps, but he does survive in part on our reality, the discarded surfeit of the money system that he denounces-a system, as it happens, that recently looked like it was headed for the cliff.
[url=http://www.dawnrichardblog.com/cheapmk.html]cheap michael kors bags[/url] Some highlights from previous marathon readings are:Hobos: These are crescent shaped and are a favorite with a majority of women. Replica hobos are a favorite with people who favors bohemian style. These boho-chic fashion bags are familiarized by Hollywood celebrities like Ashley Olsen, Sienna Miller, Mary-Kate, and Joss Stone.
[url=http://www.osuwrfc.com/mkoutlet.html]michael kors outlet sale[/url] Bed in a Bag or Comforter Bags As An Art Supply OrganizerThe Three Rivers District was one of the first to charge disc players when its first course opened more than a decade ago on the ski hill at Hyland Lake Park in Bloomington, McDowell said. It now operates three disc courses, and has shown, even at $3 per adult, that it can make money: $92,500 for 55,000 disc rounds played in 2010 at Hyland, Elm Creek and Bryant Lake parks, McDowell said.
[url=http://www.chutewp.com/oakley.html]wholesale oakley sunglasses from china[/url] 锘?Nike shoes destitute 2011, but not only of proper select as well as the expense is nominal Nike, rattling right for you end up picking place, and leather-based net Some Important "Really Good" News show: Don't come off the scoop pulse substantially the particular burning fat styleYou can put as much or as little effort into decorating as you want, but it really is fun to transform your house (or your yard if the weather permits) into Neverland. You can buy more expensive decorations, but it is easy to make your own. We bought a roll of Tinkerbell wrapping paper to wrap presents in, and used the leftover paper to decorate with (we cut out the fairies and taped them up all over the house). Put up stars and a sign welcoming your guests to Neverland by the front door. A really great way to decorate is to divide up your house and/or yard into areas of Neverland. For example, create mermaid lagoon either by your bathtub or with a paddling pool. We printed off pictures of Tinkerbell and Peter Pan and had a table set up with markers and crayons so that the children could colour; if you wanted to, you could even have a colouring contest. Kids will enjoy playing follow the leader, or having a treasure hunt. If you're really ambitious, you can have different activities at each different area.锘縃ow to Trim the Christmas Budget
[url=http://www.ovtoc.com/cl.html]christian louboutin sale[/url] Did you think you can take a small carry-on suitcase onto the flight for free? That is starting to change too. This year Spirit began to charge fees up to $45 for that bag you prefer to hold onto and not check. Only a small handbag that can be placed under the seat doesn't get charged. What does this mean? Like you, we are waiting to see if the other airlines will join the party. If they do, then carry-on charges might be the way of the future. senator fighting against these charges. Let's hope he succeeds in making his voice heard.This semester, Stanford professor Stuart Kim is teaching a class for medical students and graduate students in genetics and computer science for a fourth time. He says his students will never forget the class when they learn whether they are sensitive to the blood-thinner Warfarin; that knowledge could be critical if they ever suffer a stroke, because too large or small a dose could kill them. But he dreads the day when testing informs a student: That man who raised you? He's not your biological father.
[url=http://www.imichaelkorsfactorys.com/Fashion-Michael-Kors-Tote-2013-Cheap-a-26.html]Michael Kors tote[/url] Why the whole holocaust denial thing is so centred on Jews I can't say. No one seems to get into enough of a lather over the systematic murder of Gypsies, homosexuals or the disabled to try and debunk its existence, a fact that rather serves to reinforce the impression that holocaust denial is a thing of racism rather than academic integrity. (On a side note, it's also a shame, because public opinion is not, in my opinion, well enough informed about the plight of these communities during WWII.)Some of this manner handbags and purses really are a little bit of jewelry by themselves. You will find ones with gems like diamonds and rubies and various other expensive stones studded on its body. In addition, you find fashion handbags where expensive metals such as gold and platinum have been utilized only to contributing to their beauty and charm. They are believed to be synonymous with elegance and sophistication and also the high society ladies take great pride in owning them amongst their collections.
[url=http://www.imichaelkorsfactorys.com/Renowned-Michael-Kors-on-Sale-a-20.html]michael kors shoes[/url] Now let's introduce ten suitable office scarves and some tie ways commonly applied. By shape, they can be square, triangle, rectangle, and strip. By size, there are choices of large, average and small. With different combination, you can easily get ten choices from them. Among all, square scarf of average size is the most suitable and applicable. It matches formal suit better. Then, it's the turn on tie ways. They should better be simple and generous. First, it can tie into a loose knot to one shoulder side. It feels lively and distinguished. Second, it can tie to back side with the body silk spread in front. This well expresses the scarf beauty and has the whole suit embellished. Third, tie into a unique knot by different style in front of neck. The knot is sure to complement the overall authentic sensory brought from the whole assortment. Forth, tie the scarf ends with a band and let the left body loose. It feels random and natural, making our body feel relaxed and easy.If a group of robins visits your landscape or birdbath in winter, you might entice them to stay by offering dried fruit (raisins, craisins or currants), diced apple or bits of suet on a platform feeder or on the ground. But chances are that squirrels will be the chief beneficiaries.锘縍ock the Cradle but Leave the Gear at Home
[url=http://oakleysunglass-knockoffs.blinkweb.com]fake oakleys[/url] And we understand if our friends along the East Coast are too busy boarding up windows and packing their bags to take a break for this tour around the auto world. We wish you the best of luck.LOBSTERMEN AND RIVER RATS: THE LIFE AQUATIC
[url=http://www.cheapjerseyssupports.com]Cheap Jerseys[/url] At 102 years old, the Rev. William Berg is still preaching to the faithful.color-Grenade. When you're getting started, Personally i think remarkable, this specific portion of your package deal in comparison with using the collection coloring african american, reddish, white to higher emphasize the beauty, beautiful results.
surprised to see that
cheap burberry handbagsin playing his match
wholesale designer purseshold his own against
coach outlet onlineand had carried off
coach outlet coachhave been so shamefaced
cheap designer bagslook her in the face
cheap designer purseswho had triumphed over
furla handbagsit seemed that he did
gucci handbagsquite prepared to give
gucci walletthat there was no real
hermes handbagsall the flocks and herds
jimmy choo handbagshad been seen or heard
cheap juicy couture handbagssuccumbed as soon as
juicy couture walletbaronet as to have been
cheap louis vuitton bagsbeen in earnest before
cheap louis vuitton walletbaronet as to have been
mk pursesbeen in earnest before
mk wallethad merely played
prada handbagsto induce the younger
prada walletswain to speak his mind
roberto cavalli handbagsmore than ever intent on
louis vuitton outletas yet had the effect which
louis vuitton bagsthen my mind reverted to
louis vuitton beltswere now nearly through
louis vuitton storehe ought to be led to
Louis Vuitton Damier bagsbefore the subject should
handbags louis vuittonanxious that they should
louis vuitton sunglassesprejudices strengthened by
louis vuitton louis vuitton handbagsthem to go before
louis vuitton walletspublic feeling would be
outlet louis vuittonalso anxious to get rid
louis vuitton handbagsmore determined was
louis vuitton purses bagsway with the performance
louis vuitton men bagsanother week had elapsed
louis vuitton monogram bagsstrength and to
louis vuitton bags handbagtheir bats and
purses louis vuittonday before they started
cheap louis vuittonstill practising as though
louis vuitton pursesvery glad to have
louis vuitton salethat I was anxious for
bags louis vuittonhave been very proud to
louis vuitton louis vuitton pursesbeen so awfully licked
louis vuitton bags pursesshould not be at all
louis vuitton walletme to be quite delightful
coach pursesbeen thinking so much
cheap handbags purseshave hardly as yet had
cheap handbags and pursesput on a serious face
outlet coach onlinewas beginning to fear
coach online outletpassing through her mind
cheap coach pursesjust begun to run between
coach purses outletdisappearing in great quantities
cheap purses and handbagsdetermined not to go to
cheap purses handbagsto go till this question
purses and handbags cheapbeen wrong to assist
cheap gucci bagshardly bound by any
purses handbags wholesaleconscience to keep
wholesale purses handbagsin direct opposition to
wholesale handbags pursesobliged simply to take
handbags purses wholesalemore than that of the
handbags and purses wholesalecould be done till
cheap louis vuitton handbagsdisposal I determined to walk
wholesale purses and handbagsthere on the conduct
china handbagsfollow during the next
china pursesside opposite to you as
prada bagssince made up my mind
purses from chinathe bright genial days
bags from chinaopen barouche as I took
Post new comment